SciNatured → This Day My Way → Jury guide
For judges

Guide for the jury

Thank you for judging! This page explains how to score, what to look for, and what happens with ties, recusals and questions.

1Your role

  • The jury has up to 5 judges and changes every month. We aim for a mix, for example a child, an illustrator, a writer, an educator and someone from the community.
  • Judging is blind. You'll see each drawing with its rhyme and an entry number (for example NOV-0017), never the artist's name, age or country. Please don't try to find out who made a drawing.
  • All ages compete in one group, from 5 to 99. Don't add or take away points for how old the artist seems.
  • We judge the idea, not the technique, like real art.
  • Your name and a short bio are shown on the results page. Your individual scores stay private.

2Monthly timeline

  1. Last dayEntries close at 23:59 Toronto time.
  2. 1stYou get an email with a sign-in link to the jury page and the month's numbered drawings.
  3. 3rd, 23:59Scores due. Every judge scores every drawing in the round.
  4. 4thOrganizers check the scores and may ask you about outliers.
  5. 5thResults are published.
Please keep entries and scores confidential until the results are published on the 5th.

3What to look for

You give one overall score per drawing. These four questions help you get there. You don't need to score them separately, but let them guide you roughly in this proportion:

Idea: what did the artist make of the rhyme?Their own reading of the rhyme, not just illustrating the words literally.
≈40%
Surprise: have I seen this before?An unexpected angle, a fresh point of view, a twist.
≈25%
Story and feeling: does it make me feel or imagine something?Mood, humour, tenderness, a moment, a world beyond the frame.
≈20%
Intent: do the choices look deliberate?What's big or small, what's left out, colour used on purpose. This is about intention, not skill.
≈15%

Don't score on

  • Neat lines, realism, "correct" proportions, expensive materials
  • How old the artist seems, or how much time the drawing took
  • Photo quality, as long as you can see the drawing
  • Your personal taste in style. A scribbly drawing with a brilliant idea beats a polished, predictable one.

4Using the 1–10 scale

9–10Unforgettable. An idea you'll still think about tomorrow. Give one only when you mean it.
7–8Strong and clearly their own. Something surprising or moving.
5–6A solid response to the rhyme with a little personal touch.
3–4Mostly a literal picture of the words, with little of the artist's own idea.
1–2Hardly connected to the rhyme.
Tips: look through all the drawings once before scoring anything. Use the whole scale: if everything gets a 7, your scores don't help us choose. Whole numbers only.

5How scores are added up

  • Each drawing's final score is the average of the scores it received, worked out to two decimals (for example 8.40). With 5 judges this gives the same order as adding the scores up out of 50, and it still works when there are fewer judges or when someone steps aside.
  • The three highest averages win 1st, 2nd and 3rd place. One artist can win several places, because each drawing stands on its own.
  • We never drop the highest or lowest score. If your score differs from the others' average by 5 or more points, an organizer may ask you to look again. You can keep it, and the final call is yours.
  • If a judge can't finish all the drawings by the deadline, all of that judge's scores for the month are left out, so every drawing is judged by the same people.

Example (4 judges)

EntryABCDAveragePlace
NOV-000498988.501st
NOV-001199788.252nd (tie)
NOV-001988988.252nd (tie)
NOV-000278877.503rd

6Ties

There's no tie-break vote and no coin toss. Tied drawings share the place.

  • The tied artists split the place's prize plus a bonus of the same amount from SciNatured's prize fund, so in a two-way tie each artist gets the full prize. In a three-way tie for 3rd ($10 + $10 bonus), each gets $6.67.
  • The next highest score takes the next place. In the example above, NOV-0011 and NOV-0019 share 2nd place and get $20 each, and NOV-0002 is still 3rd. There are always a 1st, 2nd and 3rd place.
  • A tie is judged on the average to two decimals (8.25 and 8.20 are not tied).
  • The monthly prize fund is $120: prizes plus an equal reserve for tie bonuses. Whatever isn't used rolls over to the next month.

7If there are fewer than 5 judges

  • The contest runs with 3, 4 or 5 judges. Because we use averages, results are fair at any of these sizes.
  • We need at least 3 judges. If only 2 are available, the organizers either invite a replacement judge or move the deadline back by up to 48 hours, and results come out by the 7th at the latest.
  • Try to keep the mix: if the jury is small, it should still include a child or teen, and at least one person who works with words or pictures.

8Big months: entry limit and two rounds

Entries that monthUp to 100One round. Every judge scores every drawing (about 1–2 hours of work).
Entries that month101–200

Round 1 (shortlist): each drawing goes to 2 judges, so each judge sees about two-fifths of the entries. The top 25 averages go through, plus any drawing tied at the cut-off.

Round 2 (final): all judges score the shortlist from scratch. Only round 2 scores decide the places.
Entries that monthOver 200Entries close once there are 200 (announced on the site). Later drawings go to the gallery without being judged.

Limit per artist: one drawing per rhyme of the month.

9Conflicts of interest

  • Judges and their own children don't enter that month's contest.
  • If you recognize a drawing by your child, relative or a student of yours, or think you might, tell the organizers and don't score that drawing. Its average is worked out from the other judges' scores. You don't need to say who the artist is.
  • Don't discuss entries with other judges before scoring. Everyone scores on their own.

10Disputes and extras

If something seems wrong

  • If you think a drawing breaks the rules (traced, copied, AI-made, made by an adult for a child), score it as usual and flag it to the organizers: email [email protected] with its entry number. Only the organizers can disqualify an entry. If a winner is removed, everyone below moves up a place.
  • Participants send all questions to the organizers, never to judges. If anyone contacts you about the contest, forward it to [email protected].
  • Participants can ask about mistakes (a lost entry, a counting error) within 7 days of the results. Organizers reply within 14 days. Your scores are your artistic opinion and are never re-voted. The organizers' decision is final.

Judge's Favourite and gifts

  • You can name one Judge's Favourite each month, any drawing that touched you, even if it didn't place. It's an honour without money, and you can add a small gift of your own if you like.
  • You can offer a gift of equal value (a book, art supplies, a print) instead of a cash prize. The organizers decide each month which judge's gift goes to which place.